Sarasota, FL
Sarasota, FL
(Change Location)
powered by google logo white
5837 Derek Avenue
Sarasota, FL 34238
  • Monday-Friday
    7:00AM - 7:00PM
  • Saturday
    7:00AM - 6:00PM
  • Sunday
    9:00AM - 5:00PM

The Tire Choice

5837 Derek Avenue, Sarasota, FL

Free Wifi
Open Today Until 7:00PM
Hours of Operation

Mon

7am-7pm

Tue

7am-7pm

Wed

7am-7pm

Thu

7am-7pm

Fri

7am-7pm

Sat

7am-6pm

Sun

9am-5pm

The Tire Choice

Automotive Services
  • Oil Changes
  • Tires
  • Brakes
  • Wheel alignments
  • Filters
  • Coolant
  • transmission
  • and other automotive fluids
  • Shocks
  • struts
  • and suspension
  • A/C system service
  • And more...

Current Promotions at this Location

Tire Services
coupon background image
$119.99
Tire Maintenance Package
A SAFER, SMOOTHER RIDE WITH BETTER FUEL ECONOMY
Auto Maintenance
coupon background image
$169.99
Clean Air And Fuel System Package
BETTER ENGINE PERFORMANCE AND IMPROVED FUEL ECONOMY
Auto Maintenance
coupon background image
$139.99
Seasonal Package
SAFER DRIVING AND BETTER VISIBILITY IN INCLEMENT WEATHER

Search for the Perfect Tire

Auto Brands We Maintain and Service

The Tire Choice in Sarasota, FL provides scheduled maintenance on your vehicle for routine and preventative vehicle care. When you come in, we’ll pull up your car’s maintenance check list for your specific model and inspect the necessary components for your vehicles current mileage. Factory scheduled maintenance provides a good opportunity to make sure your car is performing correctly and help prevent costly future repairs. Plus The Tire Choice will save you up to 50% over the dealer!

  • Acura
  • Buick
  • Chevrolet
  • Dodge
  • Ford
  • GM
  • GMC
  • Honda
  • Hyundai
  • Jeep
  • Kia
  • Mazda
  • Nissan
  • Pontiac
  • Saturn
  • Subaru
  • Toyota
  • Volkswagen
  • Chrysler

About The Tire Choice – Sarasota

The Tire Choice is your one-stop shop in Sarasota, FL for the highest quality tires and automotive service & repairs. We carry a wide selection of name brand tires at the lowest guaranteed prices. No matter what you drive – foreign, domestic, or exotic – The Tire Choice has the best tires for your vehicle and the equipment to service it right.

Looking for more The Tire Choice locations besides what you see here? We've got you covered.
Search for Locations

Reviewed by 80 customers

Write a Review
Sort by:
5
Had a screw in my tire on Wednesday and took it to a competitor just down the street who said they couldn't look at it until Friday afternoon. I went home and called Tire Choice and was told to bring it right in. 30 minutes later my tire was fixed and I was happy. They won my business in the future.

Submitted 09/20/19

By Kevin Lasko

5
I recently stopped into Tire Choice to repair a tire that had a screw lodged in the tread. Having already been to two other tire stores that couldn't accommodate me for several hours I was happy to learn that Tire Choice could patch the tire and have me on my way in 30 minutes. Michael the store manager and his team did a great job so look no further when you need tires or service on your vehicles.....Read More

Submitted 09/13/19

By Bob Risheill

5
I was having problems with my front tires shimmying when my car reached 60 mph, and I has just returned from two paid, failed attempts to get Pep Boys to diagnose and repair. The Tire Choice quickly diagnosed a problem with the cambers and was able to replace and then balance and align my tires. When I returned to the road, I noticed that the problem was resolved. Although many times we want to go cheap, cheap is not always the answer. This visit cost me more money than I had anticipated, but I now have the satisfaction of knowing that my loved ones are driving a safely operating vehicle. Thank you Kenneth Brannen and staff.....Read More

Submitted 09/13/19

By Jenaro Morales

5
Always friendly, fast and fair service! I refuse to go anywhere else!! Today, they had me in and out for an oil change in 20 minutes, always such great people!

Submitted 09/07/19

By Taylor Acheson

5
.

Submitted 09/02/19

By JEFF

5
Very professional an excellent service

Submitted 09/01/19

By Robert Boyki

5
Very good and professional!! Great service and would recommend to anyone I knew!!

Submitted 09/01/19

By Robert Boyki

5
Great service!!!

Submitted 08/20/19

By Jason Turner

5
Everything was guud

Submitted 08/19/19

By JOHN

5
Awesome service! Got me in for a flat fix in 2 seconds!

Submitted 08/15/19

By David Norman

5
Scott was amazing at the Sarasota store. I had an emergency and he took great care of me. That's why I recommend Tire Choice

Submitted 08/15/19

By STEPHEN

5
Always friendly, quick and transparent with service. Have been using this store for a few years now.

Submitted 08/12/19

By Katie Slingsby

5
Experience was wonderful! Was given honest and fair pricing, no gimmicks or tricks, and walked out shortly after with a brand new set of tires. Definitely will return. Sean is an amazing mechanic there as well. He knows what he's doing and gets the job done promote that guy I say!!

Submitted 08/12/19

By Gabe Super

5
I highly recommend this tire shop

Submitted 08/03/19

By MARK

5
I stopped in without an appointment after I realized I had a screw stuck in my tire. They repaired it and had me on my way within 30 minutes. Great service!!

Submitted 07/30/19

By Sarah Rose

5
Really recommend Tire Choice as I called and they answered my questions. Brought my truck in and they delivered great customer service. Thanks tire choice.

Submitted 07/26/19

By Martin Silva

5
I've gone to this service center for years and they always provide quality service while making sure I don't go over my budget. I greatly appreciate Scott going above and beyond to insure that my problems are handled and that my vehicle is safe. He and Mike made it clear that they value my peace of mind and my fair treatment. They were relentless in helping me fix my issues, and I'm glad they're on my team.....Read More

Submitted 07/04/19

By Caitlin Shaw

5
Quick free great service, this place will definitely not make you buy an unneeded tire unlike the tire kingdom (the one down the street). Regardless, very content with the service!!!

Submitted 07/04/19

By steve french

4
Thank you!!

Submitted 06/29/19

By TERESA

5
Very professional job well done

Submitted 06/29/19

By Kenneth White

5
Great Service!

Submitted 06/29/19

By Martin FitzGerald

5
They were super nice and took very good care so i didn't even have to worry about a thing

Submitted 06/29/19

By Important Things

5
They gave me a top off on nitrogen in the tires at no charge. I've always liked this location over the years. Good people!

Submitted 06/25/19

By Ryan Fletcher

5
Scott was very friendly and found a solution for my flat tire. He fixed my tire and did not charge. Thanks Scott, and will return.

Submitted 06/24/19

By Greg P

5
This is the best tire store in Sarasota Florida. They are customer friendly and willing to help you get the best deal and the best quality. Plus they are very knowledgeable about the type of Tire needed for your vehicle. I am so impressed with this place. And they also have great air conditioning specials.

Submitted 06/22/19

By Janet Jorgensen

5
Great selection of tires and fast service. Gpod prices too.

Submitted 05/22/19

By Leonard Wilson

5
Very good shop, highly recommend this branch.

Submitted 05/10/19

By J Gonzalez

5
Great people, stopped by for a dash light and they were able to help me when no one else would give me the time of day Matt and his crew went above and beyond, will definitely be giving them my service going forward.

Submitted 04/30/19

By Tim Jones

5
Great

Submitted 04/29/19

By STEVE

5
It is so nice to make an appointment on line, then show up and they are ready for you. Then no extra service offers that you you don't need. just good service.

Submitted 04/10/19

By Tom Thayer

5
Great crew, awesome service, will use again

Submitted 04/04/19

By JERRY

5
These guys are Top Notch. Fast, friendly and the price for mounting a tire on a rim was fabulous. This is the place to go for all your tire and car needs. Do not go to tires plus by them as they are worthless. Thank you Tire Choice, I will recommend you every time. Located on Clark.

Submitted 03/28/19

By STEPHEN STANTON

5
Staff was on top of their game, honest and super friendly. I would recommend this place to anyone!! My Elantra was ready in no more than 25minutes ??

Submitted 03/28/19

By Frederick Gray

5
Thank you for fixing by my tire with a screw in it.

Submitted 03/21/19

By Jenn Butler

5
I was desperate to get my breaks done quickly as I had to leave to go out of town unexpectedly. Matt the Store Manager there was awesome! He was so, helpful and got me on my way quickly. Thanks for going above and beyond!!

Submitted 03/20/19

By Lynn Brown

5
Friendly and honest staff. Very efficient, and nice waiting room. Definitely first choice when it comes to auto care.

Submitted 03/12/19

By erik epp

5
Excellent Service!!! The technician Terry was extremely helpful in helping me understand what service my truck needed and was very honest with me. Terry was extremely cautious with my truck and every move he made was with caution. The service writer Scott is a wealth of knowledge and information. Scott and Terry helped me make a very educated decision. 11/10

Submitted 03/01/19

By Zachary Quattlander

5
Great price & service! Had 4 new all weather tires installed.

Submitted 02/25/19

By Mary Townes

5
Fantastic service and always timely. You guys are awesome!!

Submitted 02/16/19

By Maggie Norden

5
Great shop and great people, Matt and Scott are very helpful and very knowledgable. Will recommend to all my friends.

Submitted 02/13/19

By Peter Masterson

5
Hands down best shop in town !! Only shop in town I trust with my car . All the machines are super nice and help out with your real problems and not just made up problem to make extra money ! Never once tryed to upsell me . Definitely treated me like I was family . Plus there tires are at a great price . Seeing that I got a new tire for almost the same price as a used tire from other places .

Submitted 02/09/19

By Kron Wayne

5
I always get great timely service with The Tire Choice. Good work at a fair price.

Submitted 02/04/19

By Mark Wetzel

5
I purchased a set of tires on-line and TheTireChoice.com was a preferred installer. I just had my tires installed at store # 1265 in Sarasota FL. The entire staff was very friendly. Service was fast and flawless. Scott F. checked me in. He answered all of my questions thoroughly and honestly. My overall experience was awesome. This was my first time using TheTireChoice.com. I plan to have other auto maintenance work done there.....Read More

Submitted 02/02/19

By Geno Gainer

5
Scot turned my visit and service from a stressful situation to an easy and pleasant situation,

Submitted 01/21/19

By Joseph Kravitz

5
I had a noise under my car every time I turned right, I went to see Rick at The Tire Choice in Sarasota. Rick actually test drove my car and pulled it into a service bay. After inspecting my car he noticed the plastic inner fender liner had been rubbing against my tire. He was able to get it reattached and now my noise is gone, great job, great service. Thank you

Submitted 01/12/19

By Ted Probst

5
I woke up to a flat tire this morning, so I put my spare on and went to a Walmart near me, they could not repair due to the size tire it was, so I went to The Tire Choice in Sarasota, Rick went and checked my tire out and said no problem, we can repair it. After about 35 minutes they had my tire repaired, rebalanced and the spare tire put away. They also checked the air pressures in my other 3 tires. Great service, great price.....Read More

Submitted 01/12/19

By Bill Hagge

5
Great service, Rick is great

Submitted 01/10/19

By Jeff Smith

5
I was looking for tires and had been shopping around,The Tire Choice, was my 4th place I had called, wow, I was very impressed with Rick, the store manager, he explained all the different tires, he was very professional, and knew what he was talking about, I ended up putting Michelin tires on my Jeep, as per Rick’s recommendation. I am very satisfied. Will keep going back.

Submitted 01/10/19

By Carson Trout

5
Did a great job on my install, I had an issue and they got it taken care of right away for me.

Submitted 12/20/18

By Brian Kile

5
Highly recommend! Positive experience. Scott is friendly and gets you in/out quickly. These guys definitely exceeded my expectations. Tires seem to be perfectly balanced. My car stays very straight with hands off wheel. I'll be back!

Submitted 12/17/18

By Jon Kochevar

5
Scott was great. Friendly, in and out quickly and very satisfied with the work done.

Submitted 12/17/18

By Jon Kochevar

5
Went in with a tire that was not holding air, service was quick and professional. Will be back

Submitted 12/16/18

By R. G.

5
I had a small tire emergency and I drove straight to tires plus where I met Scott and his crew. They were very professional and assessed my vehicle right away. My car was diagnosed within 10 minutes. He told me exactly what was wrong and they’d have it fixed in 20mins or so. They got the job done efficiently and I was able to go on about my Saturday like nothing happened! Great service. Thanks Scott and team 🙂....Read More

Submitted 12/15/18

By Kari Dumont

5
Thank you for making my Sonata road ready for my 2300 mile holiday road trip! A new set of Kelly tires and an alignment and out the door at great price. I’m a repeat customer because the folks there always provide outstanding service.

Submitted 12/14/18

By Drew Thomas

5
Scott was very helpful and I felt confident letting him work on my car. Good price and fixed right!

Submitted 12/11/18

By Eric Ernst

4
Great service. Thanks Scott!!

Submitted 12/09/18

By Shere Sues

5
I was told the repair would take 30 minutes. It was closer to an hour. But I was satisfied due to the fact that there was no charge for the repair due to the fact I had purchased road hazard protection

Submitted 12/03/18

By DOANLD

5
Great service , location is a little hard to find

Submitted 12/01/18

By Dave Williams

5
After trying to get an oil change at 2 other places, on a Saturday, Rick was able to accommodate me, great service.

Submitted 12/01/18

By John Dubovoy

5
Rick is a great Manager, I do all my service for both my vehicles with The Tire Choice in Sarasota.

Submitted 11/28/18

By Wayne Hewitt

5
Great service. Definitely recommend!

Submitted 11/21/18

By Amber Shankland

5
Rick is great!

Submitted 11/16/18

By MARK

5
Went in for 2 tires and alignment, told me and showed me I needed front and rear brakes, gave me their coupon price and still had me back on the road in no time, great service, great price, and lifetime warranty on brake pads.

Submitted 11/14/18

By Chuck Hlavach

5
Right tire in stock.

Submitted 11/12/18

By PATRICK

5
Very Professional and personal

Submitted 11/09/18

By STEWART

5
Looked everywhere in Sarasota for a specific 14 in tire. Everywhere I called said don’t stock it can’t order it, until I called Tire Choice in Sarasota, they didn’t have it in stock, but took the time to find it and ordered it, had it the next day, great customer service, thank you.

Submitted 11/05/18

By Aaron Oakley

5
The best auto repair shop and tire store in all of Sarasota, keep up the great work !!!!!

Submitted 11/05/18

By David Poole

5
N/a

Submitted 11/04/18

By JOHN

5
Great service, employees that actually care about their customers, very clean store and service bays. Will definitely continue to use for my automotive needs.

Submitted 10/30/18

By Robert Miller

5
Will go back

Submitted 10/18/18

By DEBBIE

5
Always great, and always professional Thanks Rick

Submitted 10/02/18

By Larry Woolford

5
Rick needs a raise!

Submitted 09/27/18

By MICHEL

5
I believe the serviceman was Steve from the Venice. He was very professional.

Submitted 07/27/18

By Karen Greene

5
Great service and honest. What more do I need to say?

Submitted 07/18/18

By Steve Strattman

5
Tobin Nichols was the person who helped me, he was very knowledgeable and helped me find all things I need to get my car in ttip-top shape. I finally decided on a front end alignment. My car drives like it's brand new again. Tobin was great and I will be back to get the rest of my car finished and will definitely be telling my friends and family to bring their cars to him. Thank you Tobin Nichols you rock!!!....Read More

Submitted 06/05/18

By Nicole Van De Walle

5
I was taken care of properly quoted a fair price and job is done correctly and on time I will be back

Submitted 05/14/18

By PAM

5
None

Submitted 04/24/18

By RYAN

5
In and out they didn't jerk me around and they all had a great attitude. I will go back

Submitted 04/19/18

By James Phagan

5
Rick & Tobin were outstanding with my tire purchase for my CLK550~Brian the installer was top notch!

Submitted 04/13/18

By DEBRA

5
Always great service and honest repairs. Ask for Tobin

Submitted 04/03/18

By Jay Prassel