Fort Myers, FL
Fort Myers, FL
(Change Location)
powered by google logo white
5785 Bayshore Road
Fort Myers, FL 33917
  • Monday-Friday
    7:30AM - 6:30PM
  • Saturday
    7:30AM - 5:30PM
  • Sunday
    9:00AM - 4:00PM

The Tire Choice (formerly Rick Johnson)

5785 Bayshore Road, Fort Myers, FL

Free Wifi
Open Today Until 7:00PM
Hours of Operation

Mon

7:30am–6:30pm

Tue

7:30am–6:30pm

Wed

7:30am–6:30pm

Thu

7:30am–6:30pm

Fri

7:30am–6:30pm

Sat

7:30am–5:30pm

Sun

9am–4pm

The Tire Choice (formerly Rick Johnson)

Automotive Services
  • Oil Changes
  • Tires
  • Brakes
  • Wheel alignments
  • Filters
  • Coolant
  • transmission
  • and other automotive fluids
  • Shocks
  • struts
  • and suspension
  • A/C system service
  • And more...

Current Promotions at this Location

Auto Repair
coupon background image
$20 Off*
Wheel Alignment
ENSURES EVEN TREAD WEAR
Auto Repair
coupon background image
$20 Off*
ANY BRAKE PACKAGE
INCLUDES LIFETIME BRAKE PAD WARRANTY
Auto Maintenance
coupon background image
$15.99*
Conventional Oil
INCLUDES COURTESY INSPECTION

Search for the Perfect Tire

Auto Brands We Maintain and Service

The Tire Choice (formerly Rick Johnson) in Fort Myers, FL provides scheduled maintenance on your vehicle for routine and preventative vehicle care. When you come in, we’ll pull up your car’s maintenance check list for your specific model and inspect the necessary components for your vehicles current mileage. Factory scheduled maintenance provides a good opportunity to make sure your car is performing correctly and help prevent costly future repairs. Plus The Tire Choice (formerly Rick Johnson) will save you up to 50% over the dealer!

About The Tire Choice (formerly Rick Johnson) – Fort Myers

The Tire Choice (formerly Rick Johnson) is your one-stop shop in Fort Myers, FL for the highest quality tires and automotive service & repairs. We carry a wide selection of name brand tires at the lowest guaranteed prices. No matter what you drive – foreign, domestic, or exotic – The Tire Choice (formerly Rick Johnson) has the best tires for your vehicle and the equipment to service it right.

Looking for more The Tire Choice locations besides what you see here? We've got you covered.
Search for Locations

Reviewed by 127 customers

Write a Review
Sort by:
5
Great service. I got 4 brand new tires with an amazing deal. Jay is very friendly and has great hospitality. I was very satisfied with the service, and I will definitely come back when my car needs any maintenance. 🙂

Submitted 07/15/19

By Julisa Landaverde

5
Great service

Submitted 07/12/19

By Keith Leonard

5
Friendly and helpful staff

Submitted 07/01/19

By Mary Straley

5
Jay was excellent. Worked with me on getting me the best prices possible and had a genuine conversation while I waited! Very polite man, hope his hard work doesn’t go unnoticed! Appreciate you man! -Reith M

Submitted 07/01/19

By Reith Morris

5
Prefect customer service by Rob today!! Took us right in & the we had the best treatment!! Quick & efficient oil change!! Loved it!!

Submitted 06/30/19

By Debbie Kemper

5
Go see my man Jay Rich here...best service in town. Brought my brand new 2019 Dodge Challenger to him because I trust him and his crew. Much love

Submitted 06/23/19

By Tyler Bolden

3
Good place

Submitted 06/20/19

By STEVE

5
Jay great customer services help out as much as I needed

Submitted 06/20/19

By Lisvany Becerra

5
Jay got me in and out quickly for a walk in alignment. Fast, awesome service!

Submitted 06/20/19

By James Carter

5
My experience was pleasant and very professional. Anna greeted me with a smile and was very proficient

Submitted 06/19/19

By NICK

5
Anna is very friendly took great care of me.

Submitted 06/17/19

By Terri Skinner

5
Awesome service very helpful an upbeat personality

Submitted 06/17/19

By Stephanie Wagner

5
Incredibly fast and efficient. Best tire rotation and oil change I've had in years. Anna was very personable. 10/10 would recommend.

Submitted 06/16/19

By kori halbert

5
Anna and the crew did a awesome job!!

Submitted 06/16/19

By Jennifer Hall

5
Came in for a oil change Anna and gorge was amazing helpful customer service was highly appreciated well come back thanks again

Submitted 06/16/19

By Nick Martino

5
Anna and George were amazing!!!!! They took care of us right away!!! They were genuine...they were welcoming and made us feel right at home...like family!!!! It was a great experience and they were knowledgeable at what they do!!!! Hands down official spot for assistance with ur car!!!! Appreciate them a great deal!!! God bless them both!!!

Submitted 06/16/19

By Michelle Aponte

5
ANNA AND GEORGE !! Amazing! I appreciate the help from them both!! Anna made us feel welcomed and had such an amazing bubbly personality. George fixed our flat in less than 20 minutes. Amazing service! Totally recommend to everyone! Had a great conversation with Anna she was really welcoming and such a hardworking employee!!!! In and out like nothing!! Hardworking both of them!

Submitted 06/16/19

By Ariana Nicole

5
Anna and George!!! Amazing people with great personalities. They treat you like family and quick easy service. Extremely Thankful

Submitted 06/16/19

By Orlando Montes

5
Excellent service The entire staff is ablosutely amazing! Very professional and they go above and beyond for they're coustmer's .

Submitted 06/16/19

By Monica Standish

5
Was able to fit me in for oil change before driving out of town. Was able to check the tires.Anna was very nice.

Submitted 06/15/19

By Natalie Kozak

5
Anna took great care of me and my vehicle. Got a fantastic deal on a set of new tires. Great experience will come back anytime I need something.

Submitted 06/15/19

By Kenneth Rourk

5
Excellent service..... great staff looking forward to years of service with them!!

Submitted 06/15/19

By isopir8

5
Very nice customer service.

Submitted 06/15/19

By Leah Tangen

4
They were very professional and friendly

Submitted 06/13/19

By JORDAN

5
Jay is the nicest manager ever gave us buy one get one free and it helped us get our tires big thanks to him and his crew and the good tires we got !

Submitted 06/13/19

By kim shouse

5
Excellent service! Fast, honest & friendly! Anna was fantastic! Thankful to have an a great shop in the neighborhood!

Submitted 06/10/19

By Lauren Alexander

5
Very fast service. Customer friendly. Extremely helpful. A+++

Submitted 06/09/19

By Ashley Handley

5
Very fast and friendly! Amazing customer service. Extremely helpful. Will definitely come back. Anna was amazing! A+++

Submitted 06/09/19

By Ashley Handley

5
Manager and Assist Manager very knowable and helpful.

Submitted 06/08/19

By David Abney

5
Anna and Jay are very knowledgeable and my experience went quickly and efficiently Will be back for my next service

Submitted 06/07/19

By Travis Green

5
Absolutely will come back again . Anna & Jay were super helpful and went above and beyond from when I got there until I left . Best customer service I’ve ever .

Submitted 06/07/19

By Dayna Walsh

5
Will refer friends and family here.

Submitted 06/04/19

By Patrick Van Ostran

5
Excellent service, friendly and knowledgeable staff. Highly recommend Jay and Anna ??

Submitted 06/04/19

By Torrey Mitchell

5
Anna was great very help would reccomend everyone here great customer service great job everyone.??

Submitted 06/03/19

By raymond bailey

5
Jay Richardson the store manager is great and takes care of my needs every time I go to this shop. I have gotten brand new tires from this shop and oil changes done as well. Jay is knowledgeable and professional along with this shop as well. The service is pretty quick and you won’t be sitting in this place for hours waiting for your vehicle to get done. Fast service, professional, decent pricing as well.....Read More

Submitted 06/01/19

By Michaela Swiger

5
Friendly service and knowledgeable. Made the process hassle and worry free

Submitted 05/29/19

By Jordan Depirro

5
Jay was very helpful and knowledgeable. I respect his dedication for making me feel safe out there on the road and I appreciate having a trustworthy shop to take my car to. I will definitely be returning for future services!

Submitted 05/25/19

By Ginger Poff

5
Such a awesome place!! Would recommend to anyone for a friendly experience!!

Submitted 05/24/19

By Jasmine Baugher

5
Great experience! Friendly service, quick and easy.

Submitted 05/24/19

By Jade Jenkins

5
Jay was a pleasure! Very fast efficient and courtesy service!

Submitted 05/23/19

By Mike Edwards

5
Very good customer service. Better than their competitors.

Submitted 05/19/19

By Ry Todd

5
Went here to have a tire patched very honest and would not patch tire. Because it would not work I recommend this tire shop ! Jay was very friendly! I give them a 10!

Submitted 05/19/19

By Anita G. Tipton

5
Excellent service and open weekends!!!

Submitted 05/19/19

By Jennifer Lee

5
Great, friendly local place, would definitely recommend with the well explained front desk that walks you through everything.

Submitted 05/16/19

By Christopher Sengdetka

5
Nice people,good prices,I will continue to do business here,thanks Jay

Submitted 05/14/19

By Robert Miller

5
Great service, recommended Yokohama tires for replacements and could not be happier. I replaced tires on both of my cars! Will definitely go back when more service is needed.

Submitted 05/14/19

By richard kotula

5
Friendly , knowledgeable service. Jay and Jay get a high five !!!

Submitted 05/14/19

By Barbara Van Dyke

5
Very nice people and good service.

Submitted 05/14/19

By virginia love

5
Jay was very friendly and knowledgeable Great service, recommended Yokohama tires for replacements and could not be happier. I replaced tires on both of my cars! Will definitely go back when more service is needed.

Submitted 05/14/19

By richard kotula

5
Thanksss

Submitted 05/13/19

By ELIZABETH

5
Amazing service!!! Not only did these guys find the problem my vehicle was causing but they came up with a solution. They are reasonable with pricing and honest when it comes to fixing the problem. Thank you gentlemen for your service!!! I highly recommend this place to everyone who wants to find out what is going on with their vehicle and getting it fixed!!!

Submitted 05/13/19

By Stephanie Santana

5
I came in for an oil change and Victor and staff were very helpful. The service was quick and affordable!

Submitted 05/12/19

By Dee Rand

5
Friendly effective informative service.

Submitted 05/11/19

By zach rimsa

5
Very good service

Submitted 05/10/19

By Cynthia Parsons

3
Wi-Fi is needed especially if yo have to wait over two hours for work to be completed.

Submitted 05/08/19

By Charlie Galvin

5
Jay was so friendly and helpful! This will definitely be our new place to come! Thank you, Jay!!

Submitted 05/08/19

By Caren Sneddon

4
Brought our neighbors car in for an oil change. Staff was very friendly and explained about a few other things that should be done, but we're not pushy about having it done.

Submitted 05/07/19

By Robyn Johnson

5
Excellent service and very kid friendly if you have to take you little ones.

Submitted 05/07/19

By Taylor Purvis

5
Jay M was a big help and explained everything to us

Submitted 05/07/19

By Taylor Purvis

5
Friendly people, super helpful, got me in and out in time to get to class!

Submitted 05/06/19

By Abigail Vittur

5
Friendly staff, great prices. I reccomend them to everyone

Submitted 05/06/19

By Chelsea Dunaway

5
Ran over an empty plastic gas container!!!! It stuck to the bottom of my car!!!!!! Stopped here and they immediately took car of it!!!!!! Wonderful, kind, caring folks!! THANKS A MILLION

Submitted 05/06/19

By Kris Houser

5
Awesome people, great service for a reasonable price. Thanks for being open on sundays!!!

Submitted 05/05/19

By Amy Fritts

5
???!!?????????????????,???????????

Submitted 05/03/19

By Zhitao Gao

5
Good prices, friendly service. Thanks!

Submitted 05/03/19

By Joshua Weeks

5
Appreciate it for the help. Good service

Submitted 05/03/19

By Zening Qi

5
Great service! The people here were really attentive, and let me know what was wrong when I didn’t have a clue, especially Jay. Definitely would recommend this Tire Choice to anyone in the area or even passing through!

Submitted 05/02/19

By Dakotah Eddy

5
Helpful and friendly with great pricing

Submitted 05/02/19

By Cole Man

5
jay Richardson is a very passionate & productive employer. Great customer service guaranteed!!!

Submitted 04/28/19

By EVERSCIO Cash

5
Very nice and knowledgeable. Very thorough.

Submitted 04/12/19

By Denise Harvat

5
Had the tire I needed in stock and got me in and out quickly. Jay could not have been more helpful. And very reasonable price.

Submitted 04/10/19

By michael coleman

5
Tire Choice is the best and so is Jay! We have decided to make this our family repair place from now on! Jay was helpful in answering all of our questions and helped us make the best choice for getting new tires. Jay even showed us photos of the breaks in our car to show us what we might need to repair next and be on the look out for. Great service and great people!

Submitted 04/09/19

By BrigetteBby

5
Great service.

Submitted 04/02/19

By Wayne Farrow

5
Great service.

Submitted 04/02/19

By wayne farrow

5
Great customer service!! This was are second time here and Jay was extremely helpful. Thanks

Submitted 04/02/19

By Tammy Smith

5
Friendly and knowledgeable employees and great service

Submitted 04/01/19

By Bill DeMoulin

5
Employees very friendly and knowledgeable and do a great job

Submitted 04/01/19

By William DeMoulin

5
I had a pretty good experience myself here at Tire Choice. Friendly Staff. Great and quick service. I would come back again.

Submitted 04/01/19

By Billy Kirkland

5
Great service and pleasent employees

Submitted 03/31/19

By Timothy Haley

5
Very timely service. Competent and knowledgeable technicians. Recommend highly

Submitted 03/31/19

By Kathy Michaelangelo

5
“The Tire Choice” (Previously Rick Johnson) Is by far the most unique shop I have brought my vehicles to be maintained... Amazing customer service with the new manager Jay whom convinced me that i did not need new breaks! For mine are still brand NEWW!! The guys in the shop Chad showed me exactly what was going on with my clink clink noise and fixed everything for an amazingly resonable price! Honest! Through! Integrity!....Read More

Submitted 03/31/19

By MJ Connelly

5
Brought my car in for maintenance and was warmly greeted by Jay who promptly advised me about the great deals and offers they have available and took me through the check in process in a speedy and very efficient manner. All in all, the whole process was smooth and stress free from the beginning to end and the mechanics here today can be seen working really hard and efficiently from the moment I stepped in until I left. Thank you guys so much for taking care of my vehicle, you guys ROCK!....Read More

Submitted 03/30/19

By Dale Boodoo

5
Great service. Jay and his team are great

Submitted 03/29/19

By Bonnie paternoster

5
Very helpful and nice staff

Submitted 03/26/19

By phil smith

5
Jay went above and beyond to locate my warranty information from another location where I purchased the tires. And all the time with a smile on his face. Highly recommend Jay!,

Submitted 03/24/19

By Dennis Wagaman

5
Great quick and reliable service! Highly Recommend!

Submitted 03/24/19

By Carl Theodore

5
Jay has been extremely friendly and helpful. I highly recommend this location

Submitted 03/23/19

By Karen Howard

5
Don't over pay see Jay!

Submitted 03/23/19

By Lynn Murgatroyd

5
Great service

Submitted 03/18/19

By Evelyn Baikey

5
Great service

Submitted 03/18/19

By Evelyn Holland

5
Brandon there gave me an excelent price on motor mounts and a new alternator

Submitted 03/16/19

By Mark Raposa

5
Came in for an emergency tire repair and was in and out quickly. Friendly service and good price!

Submitted 03/16/19

By Ryan Blakesley

5
I noticed my rear tire was pretty low leaving work so I decided to stop by to see if they could look at it and they had no problem getting me in right away to solve the problem!!! Thank you!

Submitted 03/12/19

By Maranda H

5
The experience was painful and on my way with a set of tires I was comfortable with.

Submitted 03/11/19

By STEPHEN

5
Brian is the BEST to deal with, always helpful and Pleasant! Never leaves me hanging. Great place to go!!!

Submitted 03/08/19

By Rani Turner

3
None

Submitted 03/07/19

By Michael Werner

5
Great staff

Submitted 03/06/19

By JACK

5
Friendly great swrvice

Submitted 03/04/19

By Mike Johnson

5
Brian was so helpful

Submitted 03/04/19

By scuba steve

5
Was upset with tire company I usually use so I decided to try a new place. I am very happy with my choice to come to tire choice. The sales people are nice and service is quick.

Submitted 03/02/19

By Edward Dow

5
I have been coming here for a few years now and the work is always done in a timely manner. Their prices are always reasonable and The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. I would recomend it to anyone. Great place!

Submitted 02/27/19

By TARA BRIZZI

5
Great service !

Submitted 02/26/19

By RICK

5
Brian and Patrick were ??I have come here for years.

Submitted 02/26/19

By bonnie bilton

5
Great experience, great service, would recommend.

Submitted 02/26/19

By Nathanial Feather

5
They were Quick and reasonable price.

Submitted 02/25/19

By Abby Mckeeman

5
These guys are quick , affordable , and have great customer service . I will continue bring my vehicles here . Thanks fellas !

Submitted 02/23/19

By Rick Leiva

5
I went to the store and Brian was super helpful in getting me the tires I needed and Patrick was also helpful with the warranty on said tires, due to the place being closed Brian and Patrick helped me apply for the store credit card so I'd be able to get the tires fixed today and not have to wait for the warranty place to open. I'm glad I came here. Brian was also very nice to my 5 yr old grandson, that meant more to me than everything else. I would recommend this place to anyone. Thanks guys!....Read More

Submitted 02/23/19

By Michelle Cansler

5
Excellent service!! Second visit and I'm loving this place even better the second time 2/22/2019

Submitted 02/22/19

By Christie Lynn Aka Jasper

5
I love this place. Brian the store Manger is an honest and straight forward guy hit will take my car here anytime for tires or other maintenance work. They won't sell u anything you don't need. The tire prices are better than anywhere I've checked. I won't take my car anywhere else again

Submitted 02/22/19

By John Majewski

4
Great service, clean & friendly facility. I would recommend this place to all my friends and family.

Submitted 02/21/19

By Bob Ciccone

5
Always a great place to get service done. Fair and honest about what needs to be done. We don't go anywhere else. Say hi to Brian when you get in.

Submitted 02/20/19

By Kelly Lynn

5
I spoke with Brian and he was very helpful with the issues I had with my vehicle. The guys did a great job fixing my old car and keeping her in the road!

Submitted 02/20/19

By Chris Brooks

5
I have one suggestion, I have the road hazard on Good Year Tires, your service did not accept it. I drove 15 miles to Good Year and they could not take care of me that day. Now I had to drive 15 miles back on a tire that was damaged.Suggestion, find a way to accept the road hazard for all makes of tires that you sell.

Submitted 02/19/19

By CHARLIE

5
Patrick was very friendly and able to get my car in immediately. Oil change was performed in less than an hour with great customer service.

Submitted 02/19/19

By Lindsey Brensinger

3
Patrick was very good and was really polite and help us with everything we needed

Submitted 02/17/19

By Madison Crespo

5
Patrick was very patient and help us with everything we needed and very clean place

Submitted 02/17/19

By Madison Crespo

5
Honest and forthright, the staff at tires choice (formerly Rick Johnson's) were very helpful in making the decision to get a new vehicle instead of making countless repairs to the old one even though they could have taken me for a lot of money. A little more expensive than other service providers but you get what you pay for! I will continue to bring my vehicles here.

Submitted 02/16/19

By Joshua Michalski

5
Good guys got me in before closing to balance and rotate tires. Very friendly and helpful

Submitted 02/16/19

By Jon Bailey

5
Quick service and resonable prices

Submitted 02/15/19

By Michael Weast

5
Visited the store in North Ft Myers. Great customer service and they were prompt with my appointment and tire repair!

Submitted 02/14/19

By Robin Raney

5
Excellent experience

Submitted 02/14/19

By Chad Reynolds

5
Excellent tire shopping experience today with George and Brian! Very personal and professional. I will definitely be back and receive mend to friends. THANKS GUYS!

Submitted 02/14/19

By Dawna Pabon

5
Great customer service and great prices.

Submitted 02/13/19

By Michael Gattuso

5
Thank you for great, professional staff!

Submitted 02/12/19

By SUSAN

5
Great Service & Good prices.

Submitted 02/12/19

By Bruce Dykes

5
Great fast service nice shop.

Submitted 02/11/19

By Bob Descoteaux

5
FAST AND EASY

Submitted 02/11/19

By Sahmi SOSA